Injuries that change everything

Doctors don't use "catastrophic" as a diagnosis. Lawyers and insurers use it for injuries that permanently limit a person's life. The cases Paul M. Marriett handles in this category usually involve:

  • Traumatic brain injuries, including "mild" injuries that leave lasting problems with memory, focus, or mood;
  • Spinal cord damage, from partial loss of function to paraplegia or quadriplegia;
  • Loss of a hand, arm, foot, or leg;
  • Third-degree burns and disfiguring scars that need repeated surgery;
  • Crush injuries and multiple fractures that never fully heal.

In Chicago, these injuries usually come from the most violent crashes: a semi on the Stevenson, a motorcyclist struck on Western Avenue, a pedestrian hit on a six-lane arterial. They also come from falls on construction sites and serious workplace accidents.

Proving what the future will cost

For a broken wrist, the medical bills tell most of the story. For a spinal cord injury, the bills so far are a small fraction of the loss. The claim has to show, with evidence, what the rest of the person's life will cost. That usually takes:

  • A life care planner to project future surgeries, therapy, medication, equipment, and attendant care;
  • A vocational expert to explain how the injury limits future work;
  • An economist to put present-day value on decades of costs and lost earnings;
  • Treating physicians who can explain the prognosis to a jury.

The claim also covers home and vehicle modifications, pain and permanent disability, and the losses a spouse and family suffer. Insurers know this expert work takes time and money, which is why early offers tend to arrive before any of it is done.

When one insurance policy isn't enough

A lifetime of care almost always costs more than one driver's liability limits. Paul looks for every other source of payment: your own underinsured-motorist coverage, and sometimes a household member's; the at-fault party's umbrella policy; an employer's policy when a work vehicle was involved; and other defendants such as a trucking company, a property owner, or the maker of a defective product.

Illinois law in serious injury cases

Illinois has no statutory cap on compensatory damages in personal-injury cases, and its courts have struck down past attempts to impose one. What a jury can award is limited by the evidence, not by a fixed number.

Fault can still reduce a recovery. Under 735 ILCS 5/2-1116, your damages are reduced by your percentage of fault, and you recover nothing only if you were more than 50% responsible. In a case this large, a few percentage points can mean a great deal of money.

Deadlines: generally two years for injury claims (735 ILCS 5/13-202), two years from the death for a wrongful-death claim (740 ILCS 180/2), and one year against a local public entity such as the CTA or the City of Chicago (745 ILCS 10/8-101).

Working with Paul on a catastrophic case

Cases like these are a big reason Paul limits his caseload. He reviews the medical records himself, brings in the right experts early, and prepares to try the case if the offer doesn't cover the injury. There is no reason to hurry a settlement: it is usually better to wait until the doctors can say what long-term recovery will look like.

What a case costs

Cases like this are handled on a contingency-fee basis: no hourly bills, and the attorney fee comes out of any recovery. Clients may be responsible for litigation costs and expenses regardless of outcome. Paul M. Marriett explains exactly how that works, in writing, before you sign anything.

Frequently asked questions

What is considered a catastrophic injury?

Generally, an injury that permanently limits what a person can do: serious brain injury, spinal cord injury or paralysis, amputation, severe burns or disfigurement, and multiple traumatic injuries.

Is there a cap on damages for serious injuries in Illinois?

No. Illinois has no statutory cap on compensatory damages in personal-injury cases. The amount depends on the evidence of what the injury costs and how it changes the person's life.

The other driver only has a small policy. Is that all I can get?

Not necessarily. Your own underinsured-motorist coverage, umbrella policies, employer or commercial policies, and claims against other responsible parties can add to the recovery.

Why do catastrophic cases need so many experts?

Because the largest losses are in the future. Life care planners, vocational experts, economists, and treating doctors provide the evidence that shows a jury, or an insurer, what those future costs will be.

Should I accept an early offer to pay my bills?

Be very careful. Once you sign a release, the claim is closed for good, and early offers in serious cases rarely reflect long-term costs. Get advice first.

What does it cost to hire Paul for a catastrophic injury case?

These cases are handled on a contingency fee: no hourly fees, and the attorney fee comes out of any recovery. Clients may be responsible for litigation costs regardless of outcome. Paul explains the fee and costs in writing before you sign.

No Obligation

Don't sort this out alone.

Get a lawyer's opinion before you talk to the insurance company.